[Don't think for a second that he's missing that. Even if it's not a "stronger" reaction, it's good enough. Hitting nerves is always fun.]

Your current theory is that we're from different times... Because someone abducting us when we're like this [tapping his helmet — while in costume] just wasn't complicated enough.

[When is it ever not complicated, though...]

So, are you going to offer me a real explanation now? Or are you gonna hold out after I've been so nice and compliant?